Hi Mari/Irina

Remember last time my ticket at https://mpithemes.ticksy.com/ticket/2661255/ to which I told you a problem about:
"2) The second problem is... if a person enters the form correctly, the form submits and a notice "Form submitted, thank you, etc"... is shown to the user. If the user misses out on the email, or any required field, it also shows a notice "Please fill in the required fields, etc..".... HOWEVER, if a) the user submits the form with an INVALID email, example hi@g     and clicks "submit", there is no prompt to tell him "email is invalid". b) After user seemingly submitted the form,  there is no notice to say "form submitted"... like it normally would. Neither is there a prompt to say "not submitted due to email invalid". c) Anyway, the form was NOT submitted (I checked my email and did not receive any form if user type an invalid email). However, the user wouldn't know this, since there is no notice to tell him if form submitted or not, it just brings him back to the product page (the place where you clicked the contact us button). d) At this point, Clicking the Contact us button AGAIN (the 2nd time, after u submitted the 1st form with invalid email), the "email is invalid"  notice will show up (as per screenshot....). But then it's like too late as the user is not aware that his form was rejected in the first place.. "

To which you guys fixed the problem (giving me the screenshot https://monosnap.com/file/GHFRusQFIWOs6FjsRUhFnBe5a5zXri ). Back then I tested it it was working fine, and then I made my store LIVE. 
Afterwards I wrote in to say it wasn't working on Firefox, to which you guys fixed it again, at https://mpithemes.ticksy.com/ticket/2707146/ .


However, as I was testing out TODAY the 4.8 (using Preview mode), I found out it does not have this fix even though you mention it would be included in future versions? And then I proceed to test out my LIVE store again (4.5), and the fix seems to be gone too. There is no prompt anymore if the user enters invalid email like hi@h      . As such, what happened? Did you guys change anything such that this fix is no more? From what I can recall, you guys only fixed the 
1) Wishlist/Compare issue  https://mpithemes.ticksy.com/ticket/2745227/ 
2) Related Products for Safari https://mpithemes.ticksy.com/ticket/2745163/

So how will these 2 fixes remove the invalid email fix that you did for me in the past? Can you please check (on LIVE THEME 4.5) and let me know? Thanks..

Hi Irina/Mari

After some investigation, I realised the "invalid email" popup will come up if you do a Page/Browser REFRESH. Not sure why. Maybe you can look into this clue and see what's wrong.

Steps to recreate:
1) Go to https://www.gamestgeek.com/pages/contact-us
2) Enter an invalid email like dgfdgd@gfgdf , the rest of the fields are valid.
3) Click Submit and do a Recaptcha check if any.
4) Now it brings you back to https://www.gamestgeek.com/pages/contact-us?contact%5Bbody%5D=fdsfds&form_type=contact    WITHOUT any popup to say invalid email.  At this point, click on the Browser's Refresh button to refresh the page.
5) You will notice that after Refreshing the page, the prompt of invalid email appears. In the past, the prompt appears IMMEDIATELY after the user clicks "Submit" and the Recaptcha, so that user knows it's wrong. There was NO NEED to refresh the page. Now, it is bugged (in the sense that there is NO prompt anymore after submitting). 

Kindly check on this. This bug is happening for both the Main Contact form and the Pop-up Contact form (for both 4.5 and 4.8). I'm not sure why it happened for the 4.5 coz you already fixed it for me, and it's NOT supposed to be back. So please investigate the cause of the problem (what made the bug came back).. Thanks!

hi, but i thought you guys managed to fix it last time? Why did it changed??